DC1 – European Policy and Regulation for Sustainable, Secure and Fair Space


Marco Franzoso J.D., Adv. LL.M.

Partner Organisations

Ludovika University of Public Service (PhD awarding institution)
Thales Alenia Space France

Supervisors

Dr. Bartóki-Gönczy Balázs
Dr. Hervé Legay

Description of the Work Project

Despite possessing robust industrial and scientific foundations, and despite the global space economy being projected to reach USD 1.8 trillion by 2035, the European space ecosystem remains constrained by institutional, financial, and industrial fragmentation, while its competitors advance through unified governance structures. This PhD project charts the structural legal causes of this decline and investigates the range of institutional reforms capable of restoring Europe’s competitiveness, sustainability, and strategic autonomy in the global space economy.
The principal vulnerability identified is the probable legal incompatibility between the European Space Agency’s Geographical Return Principle (juste retour) – which allocates industrial contracts based on member state financial contributions rather than merit – and EU single market law, in particular Articles 34, 36, and 56 TFEU and the Court of Justice of the European Union’s jurisprudence on quantitative restrictions and competition-distorting measures. This incompatibility is compounded by Article 189(2) TFEU, which explicitly excludes harmonization of national space laws, entrenching regulatory fragmentation at the precise moment collective competitiveness is most needed. The research tests this diagnosis against several possible reform pathways (ranging from targeted procurement adjustments, to a reinforced ESA–EU cooperative framework, to full institutional succession) and evaluates each against criteria of legal feasibility, political viability, and competitive impact. While the research remains open to the full spectrum of solutions, it advances a clear central hypothesis: that EU absorption of ESA through a structured process of institutional succession, creating a unified European Union Space Agency (EUSA) governed by single-market principles, constitutes the most legally coherent and economically effective outcome among the alternatives examined.
Beyond this long-term institutional question, the project is equally concerned with solutions that are immediately actionable without requiring any legislative or treaty change. In particular, it develops innovative contractual instruments, including standardized trade secrets protection mechanisms and novel risk-sharing agreements for commercial space operations, all designed to harmonize practice across the European space sector and foster competition through standardized agreements operating entirely within existing EU commercial and competition law.

Core activities

  1. Development of a general theory of institutional succession between international organizations, and design of the legal reform pathways required to establish a unified European space governance architecture.
  2. Legal and doctrinal analysis of the structural incompatibility between the Geographical Return Principle and EU single market law, evaluated against alternative reform pathways (procurement reform, reinforced cooperation, institutional succession), including industry-derived case studies collected during the Thales Alenia Space secondment on procurement barriers and competitiveness constraints.
  3. Design of immediately actionable, legislation-free instruments such as standardized trade secrets protection frameworks and innovative contractual risk-sharing tools to harmonize practice and foster competition across the European space sector.

Thales Alenia Space, Toulouse,
France

Thales Alenia Space

Thales Alenia Space, Toulouse,
France (Secondment)

Ludovika University of Public Service,
Budapest, Hungary